Over 50 Questions to ask when Validating a web page

At first I thought evaluating a web search and web page was no big deal, just check a few things. When I started to brainstorm, I found I had a list of over 50 questions to ask to determine if a web page contains useful and truthful information.

The Process:
1)Evaluating your web search list to decide which links to follow
2)After selecting a hit, evaluating if this information is useful to your theme and focus and if it is
3)Determining the validity of the web site

Step 1 - Which Links to Follow

Looking at the list
•Order of the list – does being first mean it is the best?
•Are they sponsored Links?

Domain Names – how do you Read a URL’s
•The URL is a Universal Resource Locator which masks an IP address
www.componentDomainName.TopLevelDomain or www.subdomain.microsoft.com
•What is the TopLevelDomain or extension http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Internet_top-level_domains
The most common to expose children to are: .org .edu .com .k12. gov
•What Protocol – is it www or http?
•Check the Paths and directories
•Are your keywords in the URL?
•Is it a personal page? Does it contain: ~, %, or words like: aol, users, members, or people?

•Web page description Reading the paragraph under, does it provide categories?

•Before going to Plan B - Have you tried different search engine and/or keywords?

Step 2 - Would this information useful to your theme and focus?
Home page
•Is there a welcoming paragraph?
•Does it convey purpose of site?

Is it user friendly – can you find information as you navigate the site?
•Does it have an electronic table to contents?
•Does it have a site map or image map?
•Is there a logo to help you get back to the home page?
•Does each page have a title?

Links
•Are the links Current? Reputable?
•If you navigate into the web site, can you get back?
•Does a Logo bring you back to the home page?
•Is there a bread crump trail of links to help you navigate?

Is there multimedia?
•Is it informational: Videos or animations?
•Is it annoying: flashing banners, distracting animations or sounds, annoying colors? Pop Up ads

Step 3 - Validating Content - Is the information true?
1.Authority
•Who is the Author/Publisher – can you contact them? What are their Credentials?
•http://whois.domaintools.com/zapatopi.net
•Yahoo Answers: Popularity ≠ Quality
•Can the content be verified on another site?
•Does the content make sense? Could this be a bogus site?

2.What is the Purpose of web page

3.Objectivity
•Does the author provide information you don’t agree with or you think is wrong?
•Are there Stereotypes, exaggerations, over generalizations, balance of presentation
•What is the Perspective – native American, women, etc – does it offer more than one?
•Is there Bias?
•Do images confuse, provoke a reaction or unrelated to text content?

4.Timeliness – when was the page
•Date created
•Date updated

5. Compare /contrast this content on other sites
•Does it fit in with your current understanding?

6. Check the Links
•Forward and Back Links
•Do a Link search: link:thesiteURL

Sources:
Eagleton, M. B., & Dobler, E. (2007). Reading the Web: Strategies for Internet inquiry. New York: The Guilford Press

November, Alan. (2008). Web Literacy for Educators. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.